Jump to content

The Songfactor's Choice Top 10 #323


Recommended Posts

What is the ruling on dates for nominated songs that were only performed live and not in the recording studio?

Is it when the song was recorded live or when it first appeared on an album?

This applies to both my Bruce Springsteen and Joe's David Byrne picks for this week. (which incidentally is originally by Whitney Houston, not Donna Summer as stated above.)

Both songs were performed live several years before they were actually published on a live album. Any thoughts or input on this?

Kenne, this has come up before and we did exactly as you did this time - went with the earliest verifiable performance/live recording of the song.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Drowned - The Who

2. Hello Hurray - Alice Cooper

3. Holiday In Waikiki - Kinks

4. Rockaway Beach - Ramones

5. Fade Into You - Mazzy Star

6. Cygnet Committee - David Bowie

7. Paper Sun - Traffic

8. Jerk It Out - Caesars

9. Twisting By The Pool - Dire Straits

10. Sin City - Flying Burrito Brothers

Honorable Mention: The Cure, Carol King, The Drifters, Small Faces

:afro: :afro: :afro: :rockon: :rockon:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1- Cygnet Committee - David Bowie (1969)

2- Trains&Boats&Planes - Dionne Warwick (1966)

3- Twisting By the Pool - Dire Straits (1983)

4- Not the Same - Ben Folds (2001)

5- Drowned - The Who (1973)

6- Paper Sun – Traffic (1967)

7- Afterglow of Your Love - Small Faces (1969)

8- Sin City - The Flying Burrito Brothers (1969)

9- Cry a While - Bob Dylan (2001)

10-When The Party's Over-Janis Ian (1975)

OK, now it's time to get "Cygnet Committee" into the Top... :cool:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Off The Wall - Michael Jackson (1979)

2. Many Too Many - Genesis (1978)

3. Halo - Depeche Mode (1990)

4. No Diggity - Blackstreet feat. Dr. Dre (1996)

5. Hold On - En Vogue (1990)

6. Pictures of You - The Cure (1989)

7. Drowned - The Who (1973)

8. Sin City - The Flying Burrito Brothers (1969)

9. Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow - Carole King (1971)

10. A New Life - Jim James (2013)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kenne,

Rockaway Beach should be by Ramones with no 'The' in front of it.

1. Blackened - Metallica

2. Hello Hurray - Alice Cooper

3. All I Know - Screaming Trees

4. Get A Job - Hog

5. Rockaway Beach - Ramones

6. Jerk It Out - Caesars

7. Not The Same - Ben Folds

8. Afterglow Of Your Love - Small Faces

9. Drowned - The Who

10. Fade Into You - Mazzy Star

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tough week.......

1-When The Party's Over-Janis Ian (1975)

2-Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow? - Carol King (1971)

3-Dancing the Night Away - Amazing Rhythm Aces (1976)

4-I Wanna Dance With Somebody-David Byrne (2007)

5-Run, Baby Run (Back Into My Arms) - The Newbeats (1965)

6-Twisting By the Pool - Dire Straits (1983)

7-Superstar - Murray Head (1970)

8-Trains&Boats&Plan es - Dionne Warwick (1966)

9-Paper Sun – Traffic (1967)

10-Money Honey - The Drifters (1953)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What is the ruling on dates for nominated songs that were only performed live and not in the recording studio?

Is it when the song was recorded live or when it first appeared on an album?

This applies to both my Bruce Springsteen and Joe's David Byrne picks for this week. (which incidentally is originally by Whitney Houston, not Donna Summer as stated above.)

Both songs were performed live several years before they were actually published on a live album. Any thoughts or input on this?

I stand corrected and I apologize deeply to the late Donna Summer. As for the version....I just picked the best sounding version on Youtube.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Afterglow of Your Love - Small Faces (1969)

2. Paper Sun – Traffic (1967)

3. Holiday in Waikiki - The Kinks (1966)

4. Run, Baby Run (Back Into My Arms) - The Newbeats (1965)

5. Sin City - The Flying Burrito Brothers (1969)

6. Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow? - Carol King (1971)

7. Cry a While - Bob Dylan (2001)

8. Cygnet Committee - David Bowie (1969)

9. Twisting By the Pool - Dire Straits (1983)

10. When The Party's Over-Janis Ian (1975)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Hold On - En Vogue

2. Jerk It Out - Caesars

3. No Diggity - Blackstreet

4. Too Close - Next

5. Fade Into You - Mazzy Star

6. Rockaway Beach - Ramones

7. I'm Your Daddy - Weezer

8. Many Too Many - Genesis

9. Twisting By The Pool - Dire Straits

10. Off The Wall - Michael Jackson

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Paper Sun – Traffic (1967)

2. Why Can't We Live Together - Timmy Thomas (1972)

3. Superstar - Murray Head (1970)

4. Pictures of You - The Cure (1989)

5. Holiday in Waikiki - The Kinks (1966)

6. Afterglow of Your Love - Small Faces (1969)

7. Cygnet Committee - David Bowie (1969)

8. Fields of Fire – Big Country (1983)

9. Hello Hurray - Alice Cooper (1973)

10.Twisting By the Pool - Dire Straits (1983)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Because the Night - Bruce Springsteen & the E Street Band (1986)

2. A New Life - Jim James (2013)

3. Rockaway Beach - The Ramones (1977)

4. Blackened - Metallica (1988)

5. Judge, Jury and Executioner - Atoms for Peace (2013)

6. Money Honey - The Drifters (1953)

7. Pictures of You - The Cure (1989)

8. Woodpile, The - Frightened Rabbit (2013)

9. Hello Hurray - Alice Cooper (1973)

10. Fade Into You - Mazzy Star (1994)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 Fade Into You - Mazzy Star (1994)

2 Blackened - Metallica (1988)

3 Because the Night - Bruce Springsteen & the E Street Band (1986)

4 All I Know - Screaming Trees (1996)

5 Pictures of You - The Cure (1989)

6 Rockaway Beach - Ramones (1977)

7 Jerk It Out - Caesars (2002)

8 A New Life - Jim James (2013)

9 Get a Job - Hog (1996)

10 Hello Hurray - Alice Cooper (1973)

HM: Depeche Mode, Frightened Rabbit, Kinks, Dire Straits, Blackstreet, Tom Robinson, several others - tough week

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Pictures Of You - The Cure

2. Rockaway Beach - Ramones

3. Paper Sun - Traffic

4. Cygnet Committee - Bowie

5. Superstar - Murray Head

6. Cry A While - Bob Dylan

7. Off The Wall - Michael Jackson

8. Sin City - Flying Burrito Bros.

9. Why Can't We Live Together - Timmy Thomas

10. Halo - Depeche Mode

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Not the Same - Ben Folds (2001)

2. Jerk It Out - Caesars (2002)

3. I'm Your Daddy - Weezer (2009)

4. Paper Sun – Traffic (1967)

5. Blackened - Metallica (1988)

6. A New Life - Jim James (2013)

7. Hello Hurray - Alice Cooper (1973)

8. Woodpile, The - Frightened Rabbit (2013)

9. Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow? - Carol King (1971)

10. Judge, Jury and Executioner - Atoms for Peace (2013)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Sin City - The Flying Burrito Brothers (1969)

2. Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow? - Carole King (1971)

3. Superstar - Murray Head (1970

4. Hello Hurray - Alice Cooper (1973)

5. Cry a While - Bob Dylan (2001)

6. Because the Night - Bruce Springsteen & the E Street Band (1986)

7. Fade Into You - Mazzy Star (1994)

8. Dancing the Night Away - Amazing Rhythm Aces (1976)

9. Cygnet Committee - David Bowie (1969)

10. Day By Day – Robin Lamont & the Godspell Cast (1972)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

sfc2.png

1. Paper Sun – Traffic (1967) 50 points

2. Rockaway Beach - Ramones (1977) 47 points

3. Hello Hurray - Alice Cooper (1973) 42 points

4. Cygnet Committee - David Bowie (1969) 41 points

5. Superstar - Murray Head (1970) 35 points

6. Pictures Of You - The Cure (1989) 32 points, 5 votes

7. Blackened - Metallica (1988) 32 points, 4 votes

8. Will You Love Me Tomorrow? - Carole King (1971) 30 points, 6 votes

9. Jerk It Out - Caesars (2002) 30 points, 5 votes

10. Fade Into You - Mazzy Star (1994) 28 points

Link to comment
Share on other sites

sfc2.png

1. Paper Sun – Traffic (1967) 50 points

2. Rockaway Beach - Ramones (1977) 47 points

3. Hello Hurray - Alice Cooper (1973) 42 points

4. Cygnet Committee - David Bowie (1969) 41 points

5. Superstar - Murray Head (1970) 35 points

6. Pictures Of You - The Cure (1989) 32 points, 5 votes

7. Blackened - Metallica (1988) 32 points, 4 votes

8. Will You Love Me Tomorrow? - Carole King (1971) 30 points, 6 votes

9. Jerk It Out - Caesars (2002) 30 points, 5 votes

10. Fade Into You - Mazzy Star (1994) 28 points

:headphones:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...