It's a bad idea to limit yourself musically. The Killers have a lot of good music. And you can't use the McDonalds argument on me, because I listen to everything from Sun Ra to The Doors to Ugly Kid Joe to Air. So I've been exposed to just about everything music has to offer, and I still appreciate what you say "totally sucks."
That being said, I know a few people in some local bands who have been talking with Drive Thru records lately. I hope they don't get screwed!