Jump to content

daslied

Moderators
  • Posts

    3455
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by daslied

  1. 1) 75% of they're stuff is not rock 'n' roll

    2) They are overrated. I really think they were lucky to be around at that time....even more lucky than Ringo being in that band....

    1. That 75% influenced every rock band that followed them. Pretty much. :)

    2. They actually created "that time", so I don't think they were lucky. And Ringo may not be Dave Weckl, but he was the best drummer they could have had, as far as a "fit" goes.

  2. I typed this, then got called away. So it's probably too late in the discussion. What the hell, it's a bunch of gibberish anyway. :)

    ---

    It seems that people who are not fans of rap feel that way for two reasons:

    1. "Not music"

    2. "Threatening lyrics"

    I disagree on both counts. Music at its most fundamental is comprised of two elements - rhythm and melody. I don't think anyone can argue that rap doesn't have rhythm to spare. As far as melody...certainly there isn't as much melody to be found in rap as in a Beatles song, but it is there, and it's integral to the genre. I defy anyone to listen to "Roses" or "The Whole World" by Outkast, "Girls" by the Beastie Boys (gasp!) or even "Lose Yourself" by Eminem and then tell me there's no melody. The difference is that the melody is typically reserved for the "choruses" of the songs, usually referred to as "the hook". The bulk of the song is made of the rap, but what you remember is the hook. If someone asks you to sing "She Loves You" by The Beatles, are you going to sing the "You think you lost your love..." melody? No, you're going to sing the "She loves you, yeah, yeah, yeah..." part - "the hook". I'm not saying that Eminem is superior to the Beatles because he's more economical melodically. They're just different styles and approaches.

    As for the lyrics part...okay, they're not always something kids should hear, and not everyone can relate to the subject matter. But the same goes for most tv shows and movies. I've never beaten somebody up or drank Cristal, but I've also never been to space or been a sniper. In no way does that affect how much entertainment I get out of it. People need to realize that acting is a big part of the "offensive" hip-hop you hear. Like visual entertainment, it provides escapism. 50 Cent isn't going to shoot you, he wants to sell you Vitamin Water.

×
×
  • Create New...